Michael L. Carr

Of Counsel

(918) 574-3036
mike.carr@mcafeetaft.com
Tulsa

Overview

Mike Carr is a trial lawyer with more than 25 years’ experience litigating complex civil disputes in state and federal trial and appellate courts in Oklahoma and neighboring states, as well as before the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals. Over the course of his career, he has successfully defended clients against a broad range of tort claims, including those involving civil rights, employment, insurance coverage and bad faith, E&O liability, product liability, professional liability, medical malpractice, industrial accidents, trucking accidents, catastrophic workplace injuries, and wrongful death. He has additionally mediated disputes involving construction claims, auto negligence, personal injury, consumer claims, and complex business transactions.

Much of Mike’s current practice is devoted to representing insurance carriers of all sizes in litigation involving insurance coverage disputes, property damage claims, and uninsured motorist insurance claims, as well defending insurers against allegations of bad faith, breach of contract, breach of fiduciary duty, fraud, negligence, and violations of state consumer protection laws. He also counsels clients on claims handling and coverage issues and has delivered presentations to insurers nationwide on numerous issues related to liability, litigation strategy, and litigation avoidance.

A portion of Mike’s practice is dedicated to serving as outside counsel for municipal and political subdivisions for a number of claims involving civil rights, employment litigation, tort claims, and property and casualty claims.

Mike has tried more than 30 cases to verdict and is a 2006 graduate of the International Association of Defense Counsel’s Trial Academy at Stanford University. His achievements as a trial lawyer have earned him inclusion in The Best Lawyers in America (insurance law), Oklahoma Super Lawyers, elected membership in the American Board of Trial Advocates, and an AV Preeminent rating from Martindale-Hubbell.

Prior to joining McAfee & Taft, the Tulsa native worked exclusively for civil litigation firms in both Oklahoma City and Tulsa over the course of 25 years. His prior career experience includes serving as managing partner for one of those firms for 12 years.

Representative Experience

  • Obtained a unanimous jury verdict in favor of one of the nation’s largest medical reinsurance providers in a bad faith action regarding a denial of medical care to an alleged employee.  During the claim, in came to light that the owner of the business was adding his ex-wife to the company plan improperly, leading to his claim being denied.  The jury not only found in the defendant’s favor, but also granted the carrier’s counterclaim for fraud and awarded damages to the defendant.
  • Obtained a unanimous jury verdict for a large national UM auto carrier in Okmulgee County, OK.  Surveillance showed the plaintiff to be malingering, and the jury returned a unanimous verdict in 13 minutes.
  • Obtained a summary judgement ruling in federal court for an insurance carrier sued for allegations of breach of contract and breach of the duty of good faith and fair dealing in a case where plaintiff sought coverage for theft under his business policy after his office manager allegedly embezzled funds for years.
  • Obtained defense verdict for a teleradiologist client in a federal medical malpractice claim for wrongful death after a week-long trial.
  • Obtained dismissal of all federal claims – including anti-trust allegations and allegations of civil rights violations – made against a municipal client regarding allegations of discrimination in the operation of a rural airport facility.
  • Obtained defense verdict for a government entity client sued for alleged civil rights violations regarding an in-custody juvenile suicide after a two-week trial in federal court.
  • Appointed as a discovery master by a district court judge to resolve complex discovery disputes in a wrongful death case.
  • Serves as a mediator for a wide variety of cases for one of the largest mediation groups in Oklahoma.

Reported Cases

  • Gaige v. SAIA Motor Freight Line, LLC, 672 Fed. Appx 787 (2016)
  • Whittenburg v. Werner Enterprises, Inc., 561 F. 3d 1122 (2009)
  • Clinton v. State ex rel. Logan County Election Board, 2001 OK 52

Honors and Awards

  • Selected by peers for inclusion in The Best Lawyers in America (2027) 
  • Listed in Oklahoma Super Lawyers (2016–2020)
  • Rated AV Preeminent by Martindale-Hubbell Peer Review Ratings

Professional Organizations

  • Tulsa County Bar Association (Vice Chair, Municipal Law Section)
  • Oklahoma Bar Association
  • American Board of Trial Advocates
  • Defense Research Institute
  • Hudson-Hall-Wheaton American Inn of Court

    Writing Credits

  • Defending Civil Actions Under the Wiretapping Act

    July 1999 | For the Defense

Speaking Engagements

  • Modern Issues In Law: Lawyer Well-Being, Mental Health, and Professional Responsibility

    2026 OCBA Bench & Bar Conference

    April 11, 2026
    | Oklahoma City, OK
  • Risk Management and Insurance Issues Arising from the Professional Services Liability Insurance Policy

    Midwest Engineering Training Workshop

    February 19, 2026
    | Online
  • The ABCs of the CGL: Basic Content and Coverages in a Commercial General Liability Insurance Policy

    2025 Corporate Counsel Seminar

    December 10, 2025
    | Tulsa, OK
  • Litigation Strategy and Avoiding Bad Faith Liability

    Managed Care Risk Association

    2010
    | Napa, CA
  • Oklahoma, 1999
  • Arkansas, 2009
  • Cherokee Nation District Court
  • Muscogee (Creek) Nation District Court
  • Osage Nation Tribal Court
  • U.S. District Courts for the Western, Northern and Eastern Districts of Oklahoma
  • U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas
  • U.S. District Courts for the Western and Eastern Districts of Arkansas
  • U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit
  • U.S. Supreme Court
  • J.D., with distinction, University of Oklahoma, 1999
    • 2 American Jurisprudence Awards
  • B.A. (Political Science), 1996